How a Compelling Email Increased Response Rates by Over 200%

In this blog post, we’ll explore how shifting the focus from features to outcomes transformed one business’s approach, increasing its email response rate by over 200%. 

Let’s dive into the steps that can help you achieve the same success!

Outline:

  • How to Write a Compelling Email
  • The Power of a Strong Value Proposition

How to Write a Compelling Email

In the world of sales and marketing, crafting compelling emails is an art form that can significantly impact your success. At the heart of every effective sales email lies a crucial element: the value proposition. 

When thinking of sales emails, the most significant impact we can have is when we create a vision of a more beautiful future for our prospects. 

But, this vision needs to be tangible to incite action from your prospect.

A key aspect of creating this tangible, beautiful future is our value proposition. 

Over my 7-year career in sales and customer success, I've encountered value propositions ranging from downright ugly to absolutely phenomenal. 

The difference between these extremes is stark, and understanding this difference can revolutionize your approach to sales communication.

Many people, even seasoned professionals, often confuse Value Propositions with business offerings. 

This is a critical mistake. 

Your value is not in your offering's features. Your true value is in the business outcomes your offering creates.

This subtle but crucial distinction is what separates mediocre sales pitches from those that truly resonate with prospects and drive conversions.

The Power of a Strong Value Proposition

To illustrate this point, let's consider a real-world example. 

I was working with a client who provides Review Management Software for restaurants. Initially, his sales emails focused heavily on the software's capabilities: sentiment analysis, response templates, multi-platform integration. 

While these features are impressive, they weren't moving the needle in terms of sales.

As we collaborated, I continually pressed him with questions like:

  • "Why does that matter to a restaurant owner?"
  • "How does this feature translate to their bottom line?"
  • "Can you quantify the impact this has had for existing clients?"

This process led us to the true heart of his Value Proposition: His software helps restaurants get more customers, which directly translates to turning more tables and increasing profit. 

We shifted the focus from the software itself to the outcomes they deliver: on average, his clients see a 15% increase in positive reviews within three months, leading to an average revenue boost of 7-10% in the following quarter.

This reframing completely transformed his sales approach

Instead of talking about features, his emails now paint a picture of busier restaurants, happier customers, and healthier bottom lines. 

The response rate to his sales emails increased by over 200% after this shift in messaging.

To create a truly compelling value proposition, follow these steps:

  1. Identify your true value: Look beyond your product's features to understand the real-world impact it has on your clients' businesses.
  2. Measure it: Quantify this impact as much as possible. Gather data, conduct surveys, and compile case studies to put concrete numbers behind your claims.
  3. Provide referenceable client success stories: Nothing speaks louder than the success of others. Collect and share stories of how your product or service has transformed your clients' businesses.

Once you've done this groundwork, you'll be equipped to craft emails that genuinely motivate prospects to engage with your business. Your value proposition will no longer be a mere statement, but a compelling narrative of transformation and success.

Remember, in a world where inboxes are flooded with sales pitches, the key to standing out is not to sell a product but to offer a pathway to success. 

By focusing on your true value proposition, you're not just making a sale; you're inviting prospects to be part of a success story - their own.

The next time you craft a sales email, challenge yourself to go beyond the ‘what’ and focus on the ‘why’. 

Don't just tell them what you're selling; show them the future you can help create. 

That is the essence of a truly compelling email, driven by a powerful value proposition.

Schedule a demo with our team today to learn how we can help you craft compelling emails that turn prospects into customers.

Resquared symbol: four colored squares

Get more right on your inbox

Join the thousands of sales professionals using Resquared to reach local businesses

Schedule a demo